The IFoA’s Cashless Society Working Party’s (CSWP) analysis suggests that as the use of cash in our society decreases, it poses a risk to financial inclusion and threatens to widen inequalities rather than reduce them
UN Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) ‘Reduced inequalities’ includes targets and indicators to reduce economic inequalities, both within and between countries by 2030. One of the targets is ‘to empower and promote the social, economic and political inclusion of all, irrespective of age, sex, disability, race, ethnicity, origin, religion or economic or other statuses’. The IFoA’s Cashless Society Working Party’s (CSWP) analysis suggests that as the use of cash in our society decreases, it poses a risk to financial inclusion and threatens to widen inequalities rather than reduce them. Therefore, ensuring that individuals and businesses have access to useful and affordable financial products and services that meet their needs as we make this transition to a less-cash society will be essential to promoting progress against SDG 10.
A Cashless Society?
In 2008, six out of every ten transactions were cash. By 2018 it had reduced to three in ten; and the 2018 UK Payment Market Report suggests it could be as low as one in ten within the next fifteen years.
The ‘Access to Cash Review’ (the Review), published in March 2019, found that failing to manage the transition to a less-cash society would create significant risks for individuals and society. The review identified risks such as the loss of personal independence and increased risk of financial abuse and debt, as well as identifying that rural communities were particularly at risk. As well as those living in rural areas, according to the Review over 8 million adults in the UK would struggle to cope in a cashless society. Many of these people are vulnerable in one or more ways, for example living in poverty, or with physical or mental health issues.
The IFoA’s CSWP is calling for the active management of this transition. It is particularly concerned about how a lack of planning could negatively impact financial inclusion. The CSWP states that as cash reduces, a digitally-based financial inclusion program will be vital to ensure that no one is left behind. This program should include improving access to digital financial services for these groups so that they can manage their money online, including through the use of mobile money. Further elements of a digitally-based financial inclusion program proposed by the CSWP are discussed on the coping in a cashless society news page.
There are international examples of increased digitalisation revolutionising financial inclusion. The following case study explores how the mobile based financial service M-Pesa has extended access to financial services and products to previously excluded segments of the population in Kenya.
The growth of mobile money in Africa
Traditional banking services, including ATMs and commercial banking branches, are not widely accessible to all in sub-Saharan Africa. Previously, this left a large proportion of the population, particularly those who fall into the low and middle income category, without access to the formal economy. It also exposed society to crimes which are more likely to occur within a largely cash-based society including tax evasion and money laundering. However, the availability of mobile phones has enabled widespread adoption of mobile money services, such as M-PESA, and has gone some way in addressing these issues.
M-Pesa, the first mobile money service in Africa, was launched in 2007 by Kenya’s largest mobile network operator, Safaricom. For a small fee, the service allows users to send money, from an account stored on their phone, to others and to pay for bills such as rent or utilities. Users can also exchange cash for virtual currency or vice versa at participating agents, such as Safaricom outlets, petrol stations, supermarkets and selected banks and micro-finance institutions.
Since its launch, mobile money has seen significant growth in the region. As of December 2018, mobile money registered accounts in sub-Saharan Africa had reached nearly 400 million (GSM Association, 2019). In 2018, users of these accounts performed 1.7bn transactions, worth $US 26.8bn in value. Accessibility of mobile money agents has played a key role in driving customer adoption. According to the International Monetary Fund (2018), there are 1.4 million active mobile money agents in the region. This is significantly more than the 19k bank branches.
The use of mobile money has deepened financial inclusion and has benefited large proportions of the population that are still unable to access traditional banking services including those on a lower income, young adults and women. Research has found that by using the service women are able to improve their ability to save (Jack, 2016). It is estimated that this ability has lifted 2% of Kenyan households out of poverty. It has also been found that, since its launch, mobile money has increased access to essential government services in Kenya from 20% to 90% (GSM Association, 2017). This promotes further progress across a range of the SDGs including goal 1 – no poverty and goal 5 – gender equality.
The growth of M-PESA has extended beyond Africa and it now has 30 million users in 10 countries. M-Pesa services are now offered in Albania, D.R. Congo, Egypt, Ghana, India, Kenya, Lesotho, Mozambique, Romania, and Tanzania. Mobile money has proven itself to be a useful tool in developing countries for promoting financial inclusion and, ultimately, sustainable development.
Filter or search events
Cancer incidence and mortality vary by region and socioeconomic status. Modelling the structure development and trends of cancer risk is important for insurance purposes and can impact pricing and reserving in related health insurance fields such as critical illness insurance and care provision.
A panel discussion with investment representatives discussing the impact of investment on climate change and vice versa.
This event is part of The Road to Glasgow: IFoA’s Sustainability Thought Leadership Series which will provide a platform for prominent contributors so that our members and others can understand the perspectives of a wide range of parties interested in the climate debate.
Climate change is one of the greatest risks facing our world today. Addressing it will require multi-faceted solutions. Through this panel session, we will explore the different levers that can be used to meet net-zero targets including climate science and data, government engagement, and mobilising green finance.
How governments and societies collectively respond to the climate crisis is increasingly being analysed through the lens of intergenerational fairness. Our expert panel will assess and explore the extent to which inter-generous fairness is being considered in climate policies, the lessons from those countries who are leading the way on fairness and justice in climate interventions, and more.
This practical course is aimed at actuaries at any stage of their career who want to develop their own growth mindset and apply it to their work setting and personal or professional lifelong learning. The content of the course builds on the lecture given by Dr Helen Wright on Growth Mindset as part of the President’s 2021 Lecture series, and will be delivered over a period of 2 months, from mid-October to early December.
The climate crisis and the degradation of our planet will affect societies everywhere. How we address these threats will require solutions that transcend borders. As a global profession, the actuarial community is well-placed to consider and propose effective risk management solutions to help manage the climate crisis.
Content will be aimed at all actuaries looking to understand the issues surrounding mental health in insurance and in particular those looking to ensure products and processes widen access for, and are most useful to, those experiencing periods of poor mental health.