International diversity in measuring the fair value of general insurance contracts

Document description

This paper discusses international diversity in accounting for insurance contracts as reported under SII and IFRS. Relative to SII, IFRS allow considerable diversity in practice and insurance firms to match income to expenses over the term of an insurance contract in order to provide a more ‘realistic’ basis for reporting to shareholders. However those GAAPs do not employ a coherent and consistent view of how to measure the fair value of a life insurance firm’s business. The International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) has tentatively concluded that fair value should be used in accounting for insurance contracts. This paper discusses how existing GAAPs differ from fair values, simulates their impact on the profits emerging on a simple endowment policy, and proposes we also consider Solvency II as providing a broader conceptual fair value based framework within which additional risk-related disclosures can address currently unresolved conceptual and practical problems in implementing fair value for insurance contracts and related financial instruments.